WHEN JUSTICE LOSES PUBLIC CONFIDENCE: THE NIGERIAN JUDICIARY, JUSTICE LIFU AND THE CRISIS OF CREDIBILITY

An institutional critique of judicial consistency, political litigation, public confidence and the growing perception that access to justice in Nigeria is increasingly determined by wealth and political influence.

When the last hope of the common man becomes a source of anxiety

There is a statement that has endured generations of legal and political discourse in Nigeria - The judiciary is the last hope of the common man.

It is a statement that captures the moral responsibility of the courts in a constitutional democracy. When the executive becomes oppressive, when the legislature fails in its responsibilities, when political power is abused and when citizens are denied their rights, the judiciary is expected to provide refuge.

But what happens when the institution to which the ordinary citizen runs for protection becomes an object of public suspicion?

What happens when citizens begin to question whether justice is determined by the strength of legal arguments or by the financial and political influence of litigants?

What happens when two courts of coordinate jurisdiction appear to reach conflicting conclusions on substantially related questions, leaving citizens wondering which judicial pronouncement should command confidence?

These are not comfortable questions. They are, however, questions that Nigeria must confront.

The unfolding ADC leadership controversy, particularly the latest judgment delivered by Justice Peter Odo Lifu, has brought these concerns into sharp focus.

The issue is bigger than David Mark, Rauf Aregbesola, Atiku Abubakar or the African Democratic Congress. It is about the credibility of the Nigerian judiciary and the confidence that citizens must have in the impartial administration of justice.

A judiciary does not derive its enduring authority merely from the constitutional power to pronounce judgments. It derives its moral authority from the confidence of the people that those judgments are reached independently, impartially and according to law.

              


 The Justice Lifu controversy: Can a court of equal jurisdiction produce a conflicting political reality?

The most troubling aspect of the current ADC controversy is the question of judicial consistency.

On 2 July 2026, Justice Musa Liman of the Federal High Court, Abuja, dismissed Leke Abejide's suit challenging the emergence of David Mark and Rauf Aregbesola as ADC national leaders. The ADC says that judgment affirmed the legitimacy of the Mark-led National Working Committee and directed INEC to recognise the leadership.

On 5 November 2026, Justice Peter Lifu delivered a judgment in a separate suit instituted by Nafiu Bala Gombe, which invalidated the same leadership structure and consequential decisions, including the presidential primary that produced Atiku Abubakar.

The ADC argues that the second judgment conflicts with the earlier decision of a court of coordinate jurisdiction. This raises a fundamental question of judicial administration.

If a court of equal jurisdiction has already determined an issue and delivered a subsisting judgment, under what circumstances can another court of the same jurisdiction entertain a related action and arrive at an outcome that appears to undermine the earlier decision?

There are legal distinctions that must be respected. The two cases had different claimants, and the legal issues, parties, reliefs and causes of action must be examined before declaring that the later court violated the principle of judicial hierarchy or the doctrine of res judicata. But that is precisely why the judiciary must be particularly careful.

Where substantially related proceedings produce outcomes with far-reaching and apparently contradictory consequences, the courts must provide clear legal reasoning that explains the distinction between the cases.

The danger is that citizens may begin to perceive judicial proceedings as opportunities to shop for favourable judgments rather than avenues for the final and orderly resolution of disputes. This is a dangerous perception for any democracy.

The doctrine that courts of coordinate jurisdiction should not sit on appeal over decisions of one another exists for a reason. It protects judicial order, consistency and the finality of litigation. It prevents the administration of justice from descending into a contest of competing judgments.

The question is not whether a judge has the authority to hear a matter properly brought before the court. The question is whether that authority has been exercised consistently with established judicial principles and the binding effect of existing decisions. Justice Lifu's judgment must therefore withstand the fullest scrutiny of the appellate courts.

The danger of judicial shopping and the supermarket perception of justice

One of the most damaging perceptions about Nigeria's judiciary is that justice is becoming accessible in proportion to the financial resources and political connections of litigants.

The expression that the judiciary has become a supermarket where the wealthy can obtain the judgment they desire is a painful metaphor. It should not be mistaken for proof that every judge is corrupt. Nevertheless, it reflects a crisis of confidence that cannot responsibly be ignored.

Consider some available evidence.

1.     A 2025 Afrobarometer survey found that 54% of Nigerians believed that most or all judges and magistrates were involved in corruption.

2.     A 2025 HEDA report found that 65.4% of respondents rated judicial corruption as high or extremely high. Only 42.3% believed court decisions were based on merit.

3.     A Chatham House study reported that 61% of surveyed Nigerians believed judges were likely to accept bribes to influence their rulings.

4.     A 2026 Afrobarometer-related report on access to justice found that only 28% of Nigerians surveyed expressed confidence that ordinary citizens who had been wronged could obtain justice through the courts.

These findings do not establish that a particular judgment was purchased or that a particular judge is corrupt. They do, however, demonstrate that the crisis of public confidence is supported by measurable public perceptions. The implications are enormous.

When a wealthy individual approaches the court, the ordinary citizen should not have to wonder whether the litigant's financial capacity gives him an advantage over the law.

When a politically powerful person institutes proceedings, citizens should not suspect that political connections can determine the outcome.

When two courts deliver apparently conflicting decisions, the public should not be left to speculate about which litigant had the greater influence.

Justice must be blind to wealth, political affiliation, social standing and access to power.

The poor must have the same opportunity to obtain justice as the rich, and the politically powerless must enjoy the same legal protection as the politically connected.

Justice must not only be done; it must be seen to be done

This principle is central to the legitimacy of the judiciary.

Judges are human beings, but the judicial office demands a level of discipline, restraint and impartiality beyond ordinary human expectations.

A judge must not merely be neutral. The judge must conduct proceedings in a manner that leaves no reasonable basis for the public to conclude that the outcome was predetermined by considerations outside the law.

This is particularly important in politically sensitive cases.

When the leadership of a major opposition party is being litigated, the implications of a judgment extend beyond the immediate litigants. They can affect thousands of political office seekers, millions of party members and the electoral choices of citizens.

Such cases therefore demand exceptional care.

A judge handling a politically consequential dispute must demonstrate:

  1. Strict adherence to judicial precedent and binding decisions.
  2. Equal treatment of parties irrespective of their political affiliations.
  3. Careful examination of jurisdiction and the legal standing of litigants.
  4. Transparent and compelling reasoning.
  5. Timely delivery of justice without compromising due process.
  6. Sensitivity to the wider constitutional implications of the orders being made.

Judicial independence is not merely freedom from executive interference. It also requires freedom from political pressure, financial inducement, personal interests and any other influence capable of compromising impartiality.

A judgment may be legally enforceable, but if its reasoning is unclear or its relationship with existing judicial decisions is unexplained, it may deepen public distrust.

That is why the appellate courts must not only determine the legality of the latest ADC judgment; they must provide authoritative clarification of the legal questions it raises.

The judiciary is rapidly becoming another institution Nigerians are questioning

Nigeria has a serious institutional credibility problem.

The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) has repeatedly faced public criticism over electoral administration. The police have struggled with public confidence because of allegations of corruption, brutality and political interference.

The judiciary, which should provide the ultimate constitutional safeguard against institutional abuses, is now confronting its own credibility challenge.

This is particularly disturbing because the judiciary is expected to correct the failures of other institutions.

If INEC is accused of electoral manipulation, the courts should provide impartial remedies.

If the police abuse their powers, the courts should protect citizens' rights.

If the executive acts outside constitutional boundaries, the judiciary should enforce constitutional limits.

But if citizens begin to suspect that the judiciary itself is vulnerable to political influence, where do they turn? This is the fundamental institutional danger.

The judiciary cannot afford to become another institution whose decisions are received with suspicion rather than confidence.

A country can survive disagreements between political parties. It can survive electoral defeats and victories. It can even survive temporary political instability. But when citizens lose confidence in the impartiality of the institution responsible for interpreting the law and resolving disputes, the very foundation of constitutional governance becomes vulnerable.

The damage one controversial judgment can do to thousands of honest judges

There is another dimension to this discussion that deserves attention. Nigeria has many judicial officers who serve with integrity, professional competence and commitment to the rule of law. Some make enormous sacrifices to uphold justice under difficult circumstances.

Unfortunately, the misconduct of one judicial officer, where established, or a series of controversial decisions that remain inadequately explained, can damage public confidence in the entire institution. This is the tragedy of institutional reputation.

When citizens begin to associate judicial decisions with political patronage, financial influence or the interests of powerful individuals, they do not necessarily distinguish between an honest judge and a compromised one. They begin to distrust the institution as a whole.

Consequently, every controversial judgment adds to the burden of restoring public confidence.

This is why judicial officers must appreciate that they are not merely deciding cases between litigants. They are also protecting the reputation of an institution upon which the survival of constitutional democracy depends.

Justice Lifu, like every other judicial officer, is entitled to the presumption that he has acted in good faith. His judgment must be assessed through its legal reasoning, the applicable precedents and the appellate process,

The political consequences: When the courts become the principal battleground for political power

Nigeria must also confront the growing tendency for political disagreements to migrate from party structures and electoral processes into prolonged litigation. Litigation is a legitimate democratic instrument. Citizens and political parties must be free to approach the courts when their rights are violated. However, when competing political interests repeatedly seek judicial intervention in ways that generate conflicting decisions, the courts risk becoming central arenas of political competition rather than institutions that resolve disputes conclusively. The consequences can include:

  • Political uncertainty and instability.
  • Weakening of opposition party structures.
  • Disenfranchisement or exclusion of aspiring candidates.
  • Reduced confidence in electoral institutions.
  • Increased public suspicion of judicial impartiality.
  • A dangerous perception that political success depends on access to favourable judicial outcomes.

The ADC situation illustrates why this deserves urgent attention.

A leadership dispute should not become an endless judicial contest in which the party's ability to organise, select candidates and participate in elections remains uncertain. The courts should settle disputes, not inadvertently perpetuate them. And where an earlier judgment appears to have settled a substantially similar question, any subsequent proceedings must be handled with particular attention to the principles governing finality, jurisdiction and judicial consistency.

What should the Nigerian judiciary do to regain public confidence?

The National Judicial Council (NJC), the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA), the Body of Benchers and other relevant institutions must recognise that public confidence is an essential asset of the judicial system. The following measures deserve serious consideration:

Strengthen judicial accountability

The NJC should ensure that credible allegations of judicial misconduct are investigated promptly and transparently, without compromising the independence of judicial officers.

Improve transparency in politically sensitive cases

Judgments with significant constitutional and electoral implications should contain clear, comprehensive reasoning that addresses relevant precedents and explains the legal basis for the orders made.

Address multiple proceedings on substantially related disputes

Court administration should strengthen mechanisms for identifying related cases, preventing improper duplication and ensuring that conflicting proceedings are brought to the attention of the appropriate judicial authorities.

Protect judges against political and financial influence

Judicial appointments, promotions, transfers and disciplinary processes must be insulated from political patronage and undue external pressure.

 Improve access to justice for ordinary Nigerians

Legal aid, affordable litigation, efficient case management and reduced delays are essential if the poor are to enjoy the same protection of the law as the wealthy.

Encourage responsible public scrutiny

The NBA and civil society organisations should be able to examine judicial decisions, raise legitimate concerns and advocate reforms without intimidation.

Ensure speedy appellate justice

Politically consequential judgments affecting electoral participation should receive appropriate priority so that prolonged litigation does not undermine the constitutional rights of candidates and voters.

A CALL FOR JUDICIAL CAUTION: SHOULD POLITICALLY SENSITIVE CASES BE TEMPORARILY ASSIGNED ELSEWHERE?

There is another important institutional question that the National Judicial Council (NJC) and the Chief Judge of the Federal High Court should urgently consider. In view of the controversies surrounding successive judgments in the ADC leadership dispute, should politically sensitive cases involving political parties continue to be assigned to judicial officers whose previous decisions have generated substantial questions about judicial consistency and public confidence?

This is not a demand to punish judges for decisions that may be unpopular. Neither is it an attempt to intimidate judicial officers or interfere with their constitutional independence. Rather, it is a call for institutional prudence.

Where a judicial officer's handling of politically sensitive cases repeatedly generates serious controversy, particularly concerning the relationship between decisions of courts of coordinate jurisdiction, the judiciary should be willing to examine whether temporary administrative safeguards are necessary to protect the credibility of subsequent proceedings.

Accordingly, I recommend that the Chief Judge of the Federal High Court, in consultation with the appropriate judicial authorities, consider a transparent and impartial case-assignment arrangement under which politically sensitive cases involving political parties are, for the time being, assigned to other competent judicial officers, pending an appropriate review of the concerns raised by the decisions in question.

This consideration should extend to any judicial officer whose handling of politically consequential cases has generated credible and substantial questions about consistency, impartiality or compliance with established judicial principles. It should not be a measure directed at Justice Lifu alone.

Such an arrangement must be administrative, not disciplinary; temporary, not indefinite; and based on objective institutional considerations, not political pressure. It must also respect the statutory authority of the Chief Judge, applicable assignment rules and the rights of litigants.

The objective is not to determine in advance which judge should decide a political dispute or what the outcome should be. The objective is to ensure that every party approaching the court has confidence that its case will be heard in an atmosphere free from avoidable controversy and perceived institutional bias.

The judiciary must understand that public confidence is an asset that requires deliberate protection. When that confidence is threatened, institutional leadership should not wait until public suspicion becomes irreversible before taking reasonable administrative steps.

The NJC and the leadership of the Federal High Court must demonstrate that the judiciary is capable of examining its own practices, addressing legitimate concerns and protecting the integrity of the judicial process. No judge is above institutional scrutiny, just as no judge should be subjected to political victimisation for performing judicial duties. The ultimate consideration must be the credibility of justice, not the convenience of individual judicial officers.

A message to the judiciary: The robes you wear belong to the dignity of the institution

There is a solemn responsibility attached to wearing the judicial robe. It is not a symbol of personal authority, political influence or social superiority. It represents the authority of the Constitution and the collective trust of the Nigerian people.

A judge may be powerful within the courtroom, but that power is entrusted to the judge by the constitutional order. It is not personal property. The judge must therefore resist every temptation to allow external interests to influence judicial decisions.

The public must be able to approach the court without first asking who is sponsoring the opposing party, who has political access or who has the financial resources to secure a favourable outcome.

The law must be sufficient.

The Constitution must be sufficient.

The facts and evidence must be sufficient.

The judicial conscience must be sufficient.

If judges fail to protect this principle, the damage will extend far beyond the immediate litigants. It will undermine the confidence of future generations in the rule of law.

Political Panorama's concluding submission: Nigeria deserves a judiciary that the people can trust

The ADC controversy should serve as an important moment of institutional reflection.

The concern is not that the ADC must always win its cases. It must not. Neither should any political party expect favourable judgments simply because it is an opposition party. The concern is that every political party, every candidate and every Nigerian citizen must have confidence that the same legal standards apply to everyone. Where repeated judicial controversies threaten that confidence, the judiciary must demonstrate the courage to undertake institutional self-examination, including reviewing its case-assignment procedures where objectively justified. Protecting judicial independence must never become an excuse for avoiding judicial accountability.

Justice Liman's July judgment and Justice Lifu's November judgment present questions that deserve authoritative legal clarification. The fact that the cases were instituted by different claimants makes it necessary to examine their precise legal issues and orders rather than assume that one automatically nullifies the other. But the larger institutional concern remains.

When judicial decisions in politically sensitive matters repeatedly generate controversy, when citizens perceive inconsistencies in the administration of justice, and when credible surveys reveal widespread suspicion of judicial corruption, the judiciary must not respond with institutional defensiveness. It must respond with reform, transparency and demonstrable integrity.

Nigeria does not need judges who are sympathetic to the ruling party. It does not need judges who are sympathetic to the opposition. It needs judges who are sympathetic only to the Constitution, the law and the evidence before them.

The judiciary must not become a political marketplace where litigants are perceived to compete through wealth, connections and influence. It must remain a sanctuary where the weakest citizen can stand before the strongest individual and receive equal treatment under the law.

The poor should not have to become rich before they can obtain justice. The opposition should not have to belong to the ruling party before it can enjoy judicial protection. And the ordinary Nigerian should not have to know somebody in high places before believing that the law will protect him.

That is the essence of constitutional democracy.

That is the standard by which Nigeria's judiciary should be judged.

And that is the standard Nigerians deserve.

The statement that the judiciary is the last hope of the common man must not become an empty historical slogan. It must remain a living constitutional reality.

For when the people lose faith in the courts, they begin to lose faith in the law. And when faith in the law disappears, the entire democratic order is placed at risk.

 

Post a Comment

1 Comments

  1. It is a sham and a fierce attack on our hard earned democracy.

    ReplyDelete

© Just Info 2025 All Rights Reserved |Designed by SFO Creation